THEATRICAL / OTT 8.4 / 10 RATING

Elon Musk Rates Jeremy Culhane’s SNL Impression a 5/10: “Try Harder

Key Takeaways

  • The Scoop: Elon Musk publicly graded Jeremy Culhane’s SNL impersonation of him at “maybe 5/10,” telling the show it needs to “try harder.”
  • Sketch Anatomy: Culhane played an awkward, childlike Musk in a cold open where tech executives receive a CIA briefing on “honey traps,” alongside send-ups of Zuckerberg, Altman, Amodei and Thiel.
  • Comic Momentum: Culhane joined SNL in 2025 and has now played Musk in two consecutive episodes, first on Weekend Update and then in the John Mulaney-hosted cold open.

Elon Musk has issued a blunt performance review of Jeremy Culhane’s Saturday Night Live impersonation of him, scoring the bit “maybe 5/10” and declaring the show “needs to try harder.”

The verdict landed after Culhane’s Musk anchored a cold open in which a cluster of technology chiefs sit through a CIA briefing on “honey traps.”

A Midweek Grade From the Subject: Why Musk’s 5/10 Review Is Its Own Sketch

Musk didn’t stop at the number. He paired the score with a Venn diagram contrasting “Humour” and “SNL,” the sliver of overlap labeled “the good sketches.”

That graphic does more comedic work than most monologues. It reframes a performer’s impression as a referendum on the entire institution, and the institution loses.

“I’d give them maybe 5/10 for me. They need to try harder.”, Elon Musk

Culhane’s take, per the sketch, leans on an exaggerated, awkward, childlike reading of the billionaire. It is a caricature built for the cold open’s ensemble rhythm rather than solo spotlight.

The crowded frame matters. Musk’s character shares the room with portrayals of Mark Zuckerberg, Dario Amodei, Sam Altman and Peter Thiel, a lineup that spreads the joke across an entire industry.

Two Episodes, One Character: How Culhane Built a Recurring Target

Culhane arrived at SNL in 2025 and had already played Musk on Weekend Update before reprising the role in the following episode’s cold open.

Back-to-back appearances are the real story here. A featured player earning a repeat character inside two weeks signals a writer’s-room bet on the impression’s durability.

The Mulaney-hosted episode gave the sketch its widest platform, and the subject’s public reaction has now extended its shelf life well past the broadcast window.

Late-night impressions live or die on whether the real figure responds. Musk responded, and the reply functions as free promotion the show could never script.

Comedy as Combat: What a Billionaire’s Scorecard Actually Does for SNL

Every viral reaction from a powerful subject converts a Saturday sketch into a weeklong news cycle, driving clips and replays across social platforms.

That extended tail is the metric that matters for a broadcast institution competing against an endless feed of short-form comedy, monitored across our industry news desk.

The dynamic echoes how contemporary satire vehicles court controversy to stretch their reach, though here the amplification costs the network nothing.

For Culhane, the payoff is name recognition inside a brutally crowded cast. A 5/10 from the subject is, in bookable-comedy terms, a strong return.

The kicker is the calendar. With the season still running, Culhane’s Musk now carries audience anticipation into every subsequent episode, and each fresh appearance compounds the ratings value of a character the subject himself keeps advertising.

Reviewed by
Ankit Jaiswal
Chief Reviewer

Ankit Jaiswal

Editorial Director - 7+ yrs

Ankit Jaiswal is the Chief Author, covering Indian cinema and OTT releases with honest, no-filler criticism. An SEO strategist by background, he brings a research-driven approach to film writing, cutting through hype to tell you exactly what's worth your time.